Choosing an answering service vs voicemail

Voicemail is cheaper but impersonal and loses customers; phone answering services provide 24/7 availability, immediate solutions, and personal touch that makes customers feel valued.

Author
Maryum Samah
Published on
Jun 9, 2022
Read time
4 mins

If you’re in charge of a small and busy business, you probably don’t have the time to answer every single call that comes through. And this leaves you with two options – either investing in a voicemail or hiring a phone answering service

But how do you decide which option to choose between? After all, both have their benefits. Read on to learn the difference between the two, their benefits, and why you really should be investing in a phone answering service if given the option. 

What is the difference between an answering service and an answering machine? 

As you might be able to tell from its name, a phone answering service puts you in direct contact with a professional, human answering service that can handle client comms, message taking, appointment booking, and far more, all so you can focus your attention without distractions. 

And a phone answering service isn’t just for taking your calls if you happen to be busy. Should you miss a call by accident, they can catch these as well, meaning your customers will never go unanswered. 

What is a voicemail service? 

Unlike a phone answering or virtual receptionist service, a voicemail service is a simple system that allows customers to leave behind a message should you happen to miss or be busy when they call. 

Voicemails are pre-recorded, inviting the caller to leave their contact information and a brief message, so you can return their call. It’s simple, cheap, and efficient, but doesn’t lend itself well to providing immediate customer solutions. 

The benefits of using voicemail 

When it comes to the benefits of using a voicemail vs answering service, the most significant advantage voicemail has to offer is its cost-effectiveness. 

Most cell phone packages include a free voicemail box for you to use where you can record a message on your work phone that greets customers and encourages them to leave a message. The message itself can be evergreen, meaning once you’ve recorded it, you won’t have to change it. 

The disadvantages of using voicemail 

However, while this cost-effective benefit is certainly important, when it comes to voicemail vs an answering service, voicemail has significant setbacks that you need to be aware of. 

First of all, it lacks the personality and attention that a real person can offer when answering the phone and can leave customers feeling abandoned. After all, voicemails are reliant on you answering them promptly. 

Voicemails also don’t perform well in emergencies. When you’re out on the job or working after hours, it’s understandable that you won’t be available to personally answer all calls, but if you do the type of work that can involve emergency situations, missing the call can have negative consequences for yourself and your client. 

And even if missed calls are just standard requests, not picking them up immediately will typically lead to a loss of business. For example, if you have a potential customer in a hurry to choose a company or service and you don’t answer and don’t call back immediately, they’re likely to move on and try the next company. 

The benefits of using a phone answering service 

With voicemails covered, what about phone answering services? What benefits do they have to offer? 

Well, while some customers and clients might be more comfortable leaving a message and waiting for a callback, many will call your business hoping to speak to you or your staff directly. 

By outsourcing the task of dealing with phone calls to an answering service, you have a guaranteed team available to greet each caller and answer their questions. And if you do it right, this service will be available 24/7, 365 days a year. 

On top of this, speaking with another human makes potential customers feel like they’ve got the ball rolling and can proceed with working with you. And when a live person answers your business phone, customers can have questions answered and feel like they’ve been well-served. 

They simply don’t get this same feeling from leaving a message, even if you’re prompt when returning calls. 

The disadvantages of phone answering 

Naturally, a service such as this is not without its drawbacks, with the biggest being the potential for human error that comes with any live person answering the phone. 

For example, the receptionist might mistakenly give the caller the wrong information, or a message or phone number can become misplaced. However, professionals working for an answering service are very experienced and trustworthy, so this is not a common occurrence. 

On top of this, you do have to pay for a phone answering service, whereas voicemail is typically free. 

Invest in a phone answering service today 

So, now you know the difference between an answering service vs voicemail, and why phone answering is certainly the superior choice if you can afford it. And if that’s something you’re interested in using, then you should get in touch with the Moneypenny team today. 

Our team of experienced and professional receptionists are on hand 24/7 to meet all of your call needs and more. We even offer a Live Chat service for those who need it. Reach out to learn more about our different packages, and don’t forget to visit our blog for similar articles to this one. 

Abstract gradient background with blended colors including pink, red, blue, orange, and green.
Maryum Samah

Maryum Samah is a Content Marketing Manager at Moneypenny, writing practical content that helps business owners communicate more effectively with their customers.

Topics
Customer Service
Abstract gradient background with blended colors including pink, red, blue, orange, and green.
Telephone Answering Service
Abstract gradient background with blended colors including pink, red, blue, orange, and green.

Latest articles

Blog
Abstract gradient background with blended colors including pink, red, blue, orange, and green.
August 27, 2026

How Moneypenny books appointments straight into your calendar

Blog
Abstract gradient background with blended colors including pink, red, blue, orange, and green.
August 26, 2026

How Moneypenny gets your call details straight into your CRM

Blog
Abstract gradient background with blended colors including pink, red, blue, orange, and green.
August 25, 2026

Soda, Coke, or pop? What Texans really call it in 2026 (and other ways Texas talks)

Start your journey with America's best provider

What to expect:
  • The very best people & AI technology
  • Thousands of businesses on board
  • Unmatched expertise
  • Award-winning culture